CO129-100 - Sir Robinson - 1864 [9] — Page 234

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

226

Colonial funds was laid before the Legislative Council on the 5th instant, and the subject was discussed at a subsequent meeting held on the 13th instant. Out of the six members present, four were in favour of granting the Bishop a pension of £500 a year, subject to certain conditions, which will be found specified in the accompanying Resolutions.

The Colonial Treasurer, and the Acting Chief Justice dissented from these Resolutions for the reasons explained in their notes, which form Inclosures No. 2 and 3 to this despatch.

There can be no doubt that the chief difficulty which presents itself in endeavouring to deal fairly with this question is the fact, as pointed out by the dissentient members, that even if the Bishop had been a Colonial Servant, he would not yet be entitled to any pension under the terms of the Hong Kong Pension Minute; and it is thought unjust to treat a person with no claims to a pension more liberally than those who have.

Edit History

2026-05-19 07:52:16 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
226 Colonial funds was laid before the Legislative Council on the 5th instant, and the subject was discussed at a subsequent meeting held on the 13th instant. Out of the six members present, four were in favour of granting the Bishop a pension of £500 a year, subject to certain conditions, which will be found specified in the accompanying Resolutions. The Colonial Treasurer, and the Acting Chief Justice dissented from these Resolutions for the reasons explained in their notes, which form Inclosures No. 2 and 3 to this despatch. There can be no doubt that the chief difficulty which presents itself in endeavouring to deal fairly with this question is the fact, as pointed out by the dissentient members, that even if the Bishop had been a Colonial Servant, he would not yet be entitled to any pension under the terms of the Hong Kong Pension Minute; and it is thought unjust to treat a person with no claims to a pension more liberally than those who have.
Baseline (Original)
226 Colonial funds was laid before the Legislative Council on the 5th distant, and the subject was discussed at a subsequent miseting hild the 13th upon Instant. out of On that occasion four lo the six members present were in favour of granting the Prishop a sension of £500 a year, subject to certain "conditions, which will be found srecified in the accompanying so!. Resolutions. The Colonial Treasurer, and the acting chief Justice discented from there Resolutions the reasons explained in their for notes which form Inclosures we pos 2 and 3 to this despatch No 2. N3. There can be no doubt that the chief difficulty which presents itself in endeavouring to deal fairly with this question is the fact as pointed out the dissentient members, that. even by if the Bishop had been a Colonial Servant he would not as any Bension yet be entitled to under the terms of the Hougthong Pension Minute; and it is thought unjust to treat a person with no claims to a pension more liberally than those NDE
2026-05-19 07:52:16 · Baseline
View content

226

Colonial funds

was laid before the Legislative Council on the 5th distant, and the subject was

discussed at a subsequent

miseting

hild

the 13th

upon

Instant.

out of

On that occasion four

lo

the six members present were in favour of granting the Prishop a sension of £500 a year, subject to certain "conditions, which will be found srecified in the accompanying so!. Resolutions.

The Colonial Treasurer,

and the acting chief Justice

discented

from

there Resolutions

the reasons explained in their

for

notes which

form

Inclosures

we pos 2 and 3 to this despatch

No 2.

N3.

There can

be

no

doubt

that the chief difficulty which presents itself in endeavouring to deal fairly with this question is the fact as pointed out the dissentient members, that.

even

by

if the Bishop had been a Colonial Servant he would not

as

any

Bension

yet be entitled to under the terms of the Hougthong

Pension Minute; and it is

thought unjust to treat a person

with no claims to a pension

more

liberally than those

NDE

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.